The definitive ranking of the fastest-growing retail
chains
From August 2009
By David P. Schulz
Sponsored by
Hot retailers come in three general varieties:
those that grow via acquisitions, those that
open a lot of new stores and those that boost
sales by increasing productivity in existing
units.
Seven of the first 10 companies in STORES’
annual Hot 100 Retailers chart fall into the
growth-by-acquisition category, including
chart-topper DineEquity. It ranked third on last
year’s Hot 100 Retailers chart when it was still
known as IHOP, benefiting from a few months of
combined sales after acquiring the much larger
Applebee’s. As planned, company-owned Applebee’s
locations are being sold off to franchisees to
raise cash to pay down debt and to make the
Applebee’s chain similar in operation to IHOP.
With a full year as a merged entity, sales have
more than tripled even as restaurants have been
one of the more depressed segments of the
economy.
A similar story applies to Wendy’s/Arby’s.
Wendy’s was wobbling and looking to be sold last
fall when financier Norman Peltz cobbled
together a deal in which Arby’s parent Triarc
spent about $2 billion to take over Wendy’s. By
the time the fiscal year was over, it was the
Arby’s chain that was a drag on earnings, as
Wendy’s showed surprising strength with its
value menu.
Susser Holdings benefited from its 2007 purchase
of 168 Town & Country Food Stores and Village
Market grocery stores in west Texas and eastern
New Mexico, for which it paid $356 million.
Susser’s 348 other c-stores carry the Stripes
brand and its fuel centers fly a number of
different banners, though about two-thirds use
Valero.
Supermarket operators have rarely ranked very
high in the four years of the Hot 100, but A&P
is there this year by virtue of its purchase of
Pathmark Stores, another New Jersey-based
grocer. The combined company closed some
redundant and underperforming locations and
posted a $140 million loss for the year. Core
A&P units performed well, but the Pathmark
locations and price-impact Food Basics units
were a drag on earnings.
O’Reilly Automotive took a major step toward
becoming a national player with its acquisition
of CSK stores. Springfield, Mo.-based O’Reilly
recently announced it would build a new
distribution center in Colorado to supplement
support for stores in 11 western states where it
previously had no presence. Of the 1,342 stores
it acquired, O’Reilly has either consolidated or
closed 41 of the former CSK units and is hanging
the O’Reilly nameplate on the rest, a
transformation scheduled to be completed by
2011.
Ordinarily, a retailer posting same-store sales
declines of 11 percent in a year when gross
margin decreased 6.2 percent would not be
anywhere near the top of the Hot 100 Retailers
chart, but then Finlay Enterprises is not a
conventional operator. Total company sales were
$754.8 million in 2008, up 5.2 percent from the
previous year. The majority of those sales were
in leased departments at stores operated by
Macy’s, The Bon-Ton Stores, Gottschalks and Lord
& Taylor.
Licensed jewelry department sales are not
included in Hot 100 Retailer compilations, but
Finlay also operates 108 freestanding specialty
jewelry stores under the Bailey Banks & Biddle,
Carlyle and Congress flags. So with its retail
sales in department stores removed from the
equation, Finlay’s specialty stores showed a
sales increase of 38.4 percent, earning it the
No. 8 position on the Hot 100 Retailers list.
The Pantry, which describes itself as “the
leading independently operated convenience store
chain” in the Southeast, continues to grow in
bits and pieces, usually by buying out smaller
companies with a few dozen locations. Typical of
The Pantry’s modus operandi, the company
recently closed a deal to buy 38 c-stores from
Herndon Oil. The locations, which generate
annual revenues of about $152 million, are
clustered in the Mobile, Ala., area but extend
along the Gulf Coast to Louisiana, Mississippi
and Florida.
Ongoing changes to the qualifications for Hot
100 consideration have impacted the rankings –
and in some cases, led to the exclusion – of a
number of companies. In addition to being
publicly traded, Hot 100 Retailers:
• Must generate at least $300 million a year in
total revenues, up from $100 million the past
three years.
• Can be subsidiaries or divisions of
publicly-held companies engaged in
telecommunications, consumer electronics, paint
or apparel. Vitamin and dietary supplement
manufacturers with retail outlets appear on the
chart as integrated operations represented by
total revenues.
• Can be U.S. subsidiaries of a publicly-held
overseas company, like Ahold USA (Stop & Shop,
Giant Food), Delhaize America (Food Lion, Bloom,
Sweetbay) or Delek US Holdings, which sells fuel
and operates c-stores.